Nomination Clarifications 1

[flowing_river]

Reminder that your nominations must be formatted based on the guidelines in the nomination rules to be approved. Incorrectly formatted nominations will be rejected. If your nominations were rejected due to incorrect formatting, you are welcome to re-nominate them after fixing the formatting.


The Avengers (Marvel Movies)

Avengers Team Members & Clint Barton (The Avengers Marvel Movies) (Hurt Clint) - "Avengers Team Members" is too broad of a group to be accepted for this exchange. Is there a more specific group you may want to request based on our rules for groups like "Original 6 Avengers Team Members"? If so, please leave a comment with the updated group name and all the members of the group.


Doctor Who (2005)

Ninth Doctor & Echo Clara Oswald (Doctor Who) (Any Hurt) - Is "Echo Clara Oswin Oswald" a distinct, separate character from Clara Oswin Oswald?

Ninth Doctor/Echo Clara Oswald (Doctor Who) (Any Hurt) - Is "Echo Clara Oswin Oswald" a distinct, separate character from Clara Oswin Oswald?

Solo: Hurt Echo Clara Oswald (Doctor Who) - Is "Echo Clara Oswin Oswald" a distinct, separate character from Clara Oswin Oswald?


Final Fantasy XII

Bergan/Ghis (Ivalice Alliance) (Hurt Bergan) - Is there a reason why this nomination is disambiguated with "Ivalice Alliance" rather then "Final Fantasy XII" or "FF XII"? Can the disambiguation be updated to match the fandom this tag was nominated under?

Drace/Fran (Ivalice Alliance) (Hurt Fran) - Is there a reason why this nomination is disambiguated with "Ivalice Alliance" rather then "Final Fantasy XII" or "FF XII"? Can the disambiguation be updated to match the fandom this tag was nominated under?

Drace/Vayne Carudas Solidor (Ivalice Alliance) (Hurt Drace) - Is there a reason why this nomination is disambiguated with "Ivalice Alliance" rather then "Final Fantasy XII" or "FF XII"? Can the disambiguation be updated to match the fandom this tag was nominated under?

Ghis/Halim Ondore IV (Ivalice Alliance) (Hurt Ghis) - Is there a reason why this nomination is disambiguated with "Ivalice Alliance" rather then "Final Fantasy XII" or "FF XII"? Can the disambiguation be updated to match the fandom this tag was nominated under?

Halim Ondore IV/Basch fon Ronsenburg (Ivalice Alliance) Hurt Basch) - Is there a reason why this nomination is disambiguated with "Ivalice Alliance" rather then "Final Fantasy XII" or "FF XII"? Can the disambiguation be updated to match the fandom this tag was nominated under?

Reddas/Zargabaath (Ivalice Alliance) (Hurt Reddas) - Is there a reason why this nomination is disambiguated with "Ivalice Alliance" rather then "Final Fantasy XII" or "FF XII"? Can the disambiguation be updated to match the fandom this tag was nominated under?

Vossler York Azelas/Ashelia B'nargin Dalmasca/Basch fon Ronsenburg (Ivalice Alliance) (Hurt Basch) - Is there a reason why this nomination is disambiguated with "Ivalice Alliance" rather then "Final Fantasy XII" or "FF XII"? Can the disambiguation be updated to match the fandom this tag was nominated under?


Stranger Things (TV 2016)

Maxine "Max" Mayfield/Lucas Sinclair (Stranger Things) (Any Lucas) - Is the requested hurt character meant to say "Any Hurt" or "Hurt Lucas"?


Smiley Novels - John Le Carre

Ao3 seems to have the canonical fandom tags for these books under the individual book's names rather then a series name. Is there a particular reason for why you want these relationships nominated under this tag rather then the individual books? And would you be okay receiving a fanwork that draws from any of the books that would fall under this fandom tag rather then a specific book?


Feel free to comment on this post or email us with your clarifications!

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

Re: Avengers Team Members & Clint Barton (The Avengers Marvel Movies) (Hurt Clint)

Thank you for the clarification! I did, indeed, intend the Original 6 Avengers Team Members - Natasha Romanov, Steve Rogers, Tony Stark, Thor, Bruce Banner, and Clint Barton.

[flowing_river]

Thank you for the clarification! Your nomination has been approved

[stuffedtiger]

Hello, I nominated the Echo Clara Oswald tags. She is a separate character or characters who were created when Clara jumped into the Doctor’s timestream. They do not know their relationship to the original Clara and exist in different times. There is a canon tag for them but the tag doesn’t refer to a single individual but to the collection. We meet two but there are more that we never met.

[flowing_river]

Hello, thank you for the clarification! We have decided that we will not accept tags with "Echo Clara Oswald" as a character since it is a collection of characters rather then a specific character and, per our rules, we do not accept nominations along the lines of "Any Character" from a collection of characters.

You are welcome to nominate specific Echo Clara characters (e.g. "Victorian Echo Clara Oswald" or "Original Echo Clara Oswald Character" etc.) you may be interested in receiving and those will be accepted for this exchange.

[skazka]

JLC nominator here -- I was looking to nominate some characters/pairings who appear in different novels within the same continuity, but in hindsight (looking at my empty nom spots) I could probably have nominated them separately anyway. I'm going to edit my nominations accordingly.

[flowing_river]

Thank you for the clarification! Your nominations has been approved